From advocate to adversary when the selling agent becomes your buyer
Skip to main contentSkip to main navigation menuAccessibility MenuEmail Me(661) 888-4983**(661)888-4983
**Facebook**Twitter**Instagram**YouTube
From advocate to adversary when the selling agent becomes your buyer
Connor “with Honor” MacIvor - January 25, 2025** Tags: [Real estate](/-/Blog/tag/Real estate), [agent as buyer](/-/Blog/tag/agent as buyer), [conflict of interest](/-/Blog/tag/conflict of interest), [selling a home](/-/Blog/tag/selling a home), [dual agency](/-/Blog/tag/dual agency), [real estate ethics](/-/Blog/tag/real estate ethics), [property flipping](/-/Blog/tag/property flipping), [real estate disclosures](/-/Blog/tag/real estate disclosures), [listing agent](/-/Blog/tag/listing agent), [real estate blog](/-/Blog/tag/real estate blog) ** 0 Comments | Add Comment
From Advocate to Adversary: When Your Selling Agent Becomes Your Buyer
Author’s Note: Thank you for stopping by! Below is a comprehensive exploration—approximately 4,500 words—on the subject of real estate agents who shift roles from representing you as the seller to becoming the buyer of your property. Per your request, I’ve embedded the YouTube Short, included internal links to your website (placeholder URLs unless otherwise specified), and removed any emojis. If you’d like additional or specific links, please share your sitemap or indicate which pages you’d like referenced in detail. Also, if you need a full transcription of the video, let me know!
Real estate is one of the most significant and emotionally charged transactions in a person’s lifetime. Whether you’re selling a beloved family home or purchasing your first property, the stakes are high—financially and personally. Under normal circumstances, you’d hire an agent you trust to navigate the complexities of the market, list your home at a fair price, and negotiate on your behalf. But what happens when that same agent—your advocate—suddenly says, “I’d be interested in buying your house myself”? This shift can create a potential conflict of interest that might leave you questioning their motives, their numbers, and whether you’re truly getting a market-based offer.
In this in-depth blog post, we’ll explore the nuances of agent-buyer scenarios, why it can feel like an ethical gray area, how to spot red flags, and the best steps you can take to protect your interests. The journey ahead is comprehensive, so feel free to scroll and skim the headings that matter most to you. Let’s dive in!
1. The Traditional Role of a Real Estate Agent
Before we examine the peculiar territory of an agent becoming your buyer, it’s essential to understand the traditional role of a real estate agent representing a seller. Generally, a listing agent:
In this traditional model, your agent’s success is directly tied to how well they represent your interests. The higher the sale price—and the smoother the process—the more satisfied you are, and the more they fulfill their fiduciary duty. Usually, this arrangement works because the agent’s financial incentive aligns with maximizing your home’s final sale price.
2. When the Agent Shifts Gears and Buys Your Home
The potential conflict arises when your listing agent says, “Instead of listing this on the open market, I can buy it from you directly.” While this offer might sound convenient, it flips the usual incentives. Now, instead of working to get you top dollar, the agent could theoretically aim to purchase your house at the lowest possible price—especially if the plan is to flip or rent it later. This isn’t automatically unethical or illegal, but it absolutely demands heightened transparency.
In the Home Selling Tips section of our website, we stress the importance of understanding how your agent arrives at any recommended list price. The same principle applies here, perhaps even more critically. You need clear, data-driven evidence that your home is valued fairly, not artificially deflated for a quick in-house sale.
3. The Information Imbalance
One of the main reasons this scenario can feel unsettling is the inherent imbalance of information. Your agent, in preparing to list your home, has typically done a deep dive into recent comparable sales, local market trends, and your property’s unique features. This insider knowledge, which should have been used to secure you the highest possible price, might now be re-purposed for the agent’s direct benefit.
In other words, if your agent knows your timeline is urgent—or that you’re extremely motivated to sell—they could leverage that information to make a lower offer. While most real estate professionals take their fiduciary duties seriously, the potential for abuse exists, which is why thorough due diligence is crucial when an agent transitions from advocate to adversary (buyer).
4. The Importance of Actual Market Data
In the snippet from the video, the question arises: “How do you know that what your agent is telling you is based on real market statistics or genuine data?” This is vital. Anyone can create a polished spreadsheet claiming “market value.” Ask your agent-buyer to substantiate those numbers with:
Need more guidance on vetting data or analyzing comps? Check out our Real Estate Market Update page, where we regularly post data-driven insights to help buyers and sellers make informed decisions.
5. Common Motivations for Agent-Buyers
Why would your agent want to buy your property? Motivations vary, but common scenarios include:
Each of these motivations might affect the offer price. For example, a fix-and-flip investor usually calculates a purchase price that allows for repair costs and a profit margin. A buy-and-hold investor might be more interested in the rental yield and the property’s potential appreciation. Knowing an agent’s end goal can help you assess the fairness of their offer.
6. Disclosure and Transparency
Real estate laws vary by state, but most require clear disclosure when an agent has a personal interest in a property. In California, for instance, agents must disclose if they stand to gain personally from a transaction. This includes letting you know if they intend to resell, rent, or occupy the home. Failure to disclose can lead to legal ramifications and ethics violations.
As a seller, you should absolutely request any disclosures in writing. Ask pointed questions such as:
Don’t hesitate to consult with a real estate attorney if you sense any lack of clarity.
7. Could You Be Leaving Money on the Table?
One of the biggest dangers in selling to your own agent is missing out on the broader market. A home listed publicly could attract multiple offers, potentially driving up the final sale price. If you agree to a direct sale, you may never know whether someone else would have paid more. While a straightforward transaction might save you time or reduce stress, it might also reduce your profit.
To avoid regrets, consider requesting that your agent list the property on the open market for a set period—say 7 to 14 days—before you entertain a direct purchase offer from them. This approach allows you to gauge genuine interest from other parties and compare offers more confidently.
8. Negotiating Repairs, Upgrades, and Staging
In a standard listing, your agent typically advises you on minor upgrades, staging tips, and repairs to bolster your home’s market value. But if the agent is also the buyer, any mention of repairs might serve to justify a lower offer. They could argue that the property requires extensive work, subtracting an inflated figure from the fair market value to arrive at their purchase price.
Of course, some homes genuinely need upgrades, and a buyer has every right to factor repair costs into their offer. The key is verifying that these costs are legitimate. Consider getting an independent contractor’s estimate or a second opinion from a different real estate professional. Authentic data can help you separate fact from fiction when deciding how repairs impact your home’s value.
9. Fiduciary Duty: What It Means and Why It Matters
Real estate agents owe a fiduciary duty to their clients—meaning they must act in your best interests, place your interests above their own, and disclose any relevant information that could affect your decision-making. When your agent decides they want to become the buyer, this fiduciary responsibility doesn’t vanish. However, its application becomes more complicated. The agent has to walk a fine line between fulfilling their legal obligations and pursuing a personal investment opportunity.
If you feel the slightest bit uncomfortable, ask yourself whether you trust this individual to maintain ethical standards in both roles. If the answer is “no,” it might be time to seek a second opinion or even terminate the listing agreement (subject to any contractual obligations) and find a different agent.
10. The Legal Landscape
Regulations surrounding dual agency (representing both buyer and seller in the same transaction) and self-dealing vary significantly from state to state. While some states outlaw dual agency outright, California allows it under certain conditions. However, when the agent themselves is the buyer, this goes beyond even standard dual agency. The legal intricacies can be vast, so always consult local real estate laws and consider hiring a lawyer if you sense any gray areas.
For more on the legal aspects of real estate transactions, see the Legal Resources page on our website. (If you have a particular sitemap or URL in mind, let me know, and I’ll update accordingly.)
11. Questions Every Seller Should Ask
When your agent transitions from “I’ll represent you” to “I’ll buy your house,” it’s wise to pivot into an investigative mode. Here are some crucial questions:
Asking these questions can shed light on whether you’re getting a fair deal or being shortchanged.
12. The Buyer’s Perspective: Is It Always Bad?
If you’re a buyer or investor reading this, you might wonder if it’s ethically wrong to purchase a home directly from a client you once represented. The answer can vary. Some agents argue that they’re providing a helpful solution—perhaps the seller wants a quick, hassle-free sale and finds it easier to negotiate with someone they already know.
What matters most is transparent communication. Both parties should understand each other’s intentions and confirm, in writing, that the agent is not withholding potential better offers. Many brokerages have internal protocols requiring multiple disclosures and sometimes even managerial approvals before an agent can buy a client’s property. When properly disclosed and handled, these scenarios can be beneficial to both sides.
13. Real-Life Examples and Case Studies
To illustrate how varied these situations can be, let’s consider a couple of hypothetical examples:
Case Study A: A seller needs to relocate immediately due to a new job. They don’t have the time or funds for staging or repairs, and they prefer a quick close. The agent offers a cash purchase at a fair—though slightly below-market—price. Because time is of the essence, the seller accepts, feeling that the certainty outweighs the potential for a marginally higher price on the open market. Both parties leave satisfied.
Case Study B: Another seller invests heavily in renovating their home based on their agent’s advice, incurring thousands in costs for a promised “maximum return.” At the last minute, the agent claims the market has shifted and offers to buy the property directly for a price significantly less than the updated home’s potential value. The seller feels misled and suspects the agent used them to transform the property into a profitable flip opportunity.
In both examples, the difference lies in the transparency of information, the timing, and the seller’s goals. This underlines how each situation is unique and must be evaluated on its own merits.
14. The Role of Appraisals and Inspections
When an agent is also the buyer, it’s prudent to insist on an independent appraisal and inspection. Usually, in a conventional sale, the buyer’s lender requires an appraisal to confirm the loan amount is justified. But if the agent is paying cash or using alternative financing, they might suggest skipping some of these steps. Resist the urge to forgo an appraisal—it’s an unbiased measure of your home’s fair market value and protects you from underpricing.
Additionally, inspections are crucial. If a buyer claims your property needs major repairs, let a qualified inspector verify those claims. This helps you understand what truly needs attention and whether the buyer’s cost estimates are realistic or inflated.
15. The Negotiation Dance
Negotiation dynamics shift significantly when your agent stands to benefit on the buying side. Typically, you’d rely on your listing agent to guide you through offers and counteroffers. But if they’re the buyer, you’re essentially negotiating directly with them. Ensure that every step of the negotiation process is documented, and consider bringing in a neutral third party—such as a real estate attorney or an unbiased broker colleague—to oversee the negotiations. This adds an extra layer of fairness.
16. Red Flags to Watch Out For
Below are some warning signs that your agent’s offer might not be entirely above-board:
If you encounter any of these red flags, press for clarity or consult another professional. It’s your right as a seller to ensure you’re getting a fair shake.
17. Potential Benefits of Selling to Your Agent
While we’ve spent a significant portion of this post outlining concerns, it’s only fair to mention the potential benefits:
For some sellers—especially those in a hurry or those who don’t want the hassle of a full-blown listing process—these perks can be attractive. The key is ensuring that convenience doesn’t come at the cost of fairness or financial well-being.
18. Protecting Yourself: Legal Steps and Documentation
Whenever an agent wants to buy your home directly, document everything. This includes:
In some cases, you might also draft a hold-harmless agreement specifying that you understand the potential conflict but still choose to proceed. Always remember you have the right to consult with legal counsel to confirm you’re not being taken advantage of.
19. Power Dynamics and Emotional Stakes
Don’t underestimate the emotional aspect of selling or buying a home, especially if you’ve built a rapport with your agent. You might feel guilty rejecting their offer or suspicious that you’re being manipulated. These emotional elements can cloud judgment. When in doubt, step back and view the situation from a purely financial perspective. Pretend this is a third-party buyer and ask if the deal is favorable to you. If not, negotiate or walk away.
20. Common Misconceptions
Below are misconceptions that often surface in agent-buyer scenarios:
Understanding these nuances can help you remain calm, cautious, and clear-headed when evaluating an agent’s direct offer.
21. Practical Advice for Sellers
If you’re currently in this situation, here’s some actionable guidance:
For more in-depth strategies, visit our Home Selling Tips page, which covers best practices for listing your property, vetting agents, and navigating negotiations.
22. Practical Advice for Agents
On the flip side, if you’re an agent considering buying a client’s property, be sure to:
23. The Influence of Technology
Today’s real estate transactions are often facilitated by online tools and digital platforms—think listing websites, virtual tours, and automated valuation models (AVMs). While technology can help verify an agent’s price estimate (for example, cross-referencing Zillow’s “Zestimate” with Realtor.com’s valuation), these should be taken as starting points rather than definitive markers of value. A licensed appraiser or a well-researched CMA usually provides more accurate numbers.
24. Deep Dive Case Studies
Let’s explore two more hypothetical scenarios to illustrate how complex this can get:
Case Study C (Inherited Property): You inherit a home in a desirable location but don’t want the hassle of repairs, estate sales, or open houses. Your agent offers to buy the property “as is” at a price that’s around 15% below the estimated market value. You, however, find the offer acceptable due to the speed and simplicity it provides. In this scenario, transparency and a second opinion are still key, but the outcome can be mutually beneficial if you value convenience over potentially higher profit.
Case Study D (Market Shift): Your agent listed the home for a couple of weeks, and the market took a sudden dip. Interest rates rose, and several buyers backed out. Now, the agent steps in with an all-cash offer significantly below the original list price. Is this opportunistic or simply the new reality of the market? A thorough review of current comps and an analysis of the shifting landscape can clarify whether the agent’s offer is fair or exploitative.
25. Handling Disputes and Resolutions
If you reach an impasse or feel misled, you have options. You can:
Legal battles can be time-consuming and expensive, so it’s usually best to address any concerns early in the process and keep detailed records of every interaction.
26. Impact on the Real Estate Market
Agent-buyer transactions can slightly distort how home sale data appears in local market reports. If these sales happen off-market or at prices below typical comps, it might skew average or median sale prices for the neighborhood. While one or two such deals won’t drastically alter market metrics, a larger trend of agent-buyer purchases in a tight inventory market could have a modest impact on local price data. For a snapshot of how sales in your area are trending, visit our Real Estate Market Update page.
27. The Future of Real Estate Transactions
With the rise of iBuyers (instant buyers like Opendoor, Zillow Offers, etc.) and new business models, the concept of your real estate “representative” also being a direct purchaser may become more common. The lines between traditional brokerages, investment companies, and tech-driven solutions continue to blur. This evolution could make transactions faster for consumers who want convenience, but it also underscores the need for rigorous disclosure and consumer education.
28. Step-by-Step Process for Sellers Facing an Agent-Buyer Scenario
29. The Value of Second Opinions
It can’t be overstated: if your agent wants to buy your house, always get an outside perspective. Whether from another agent, an appraiser, or a legal advisor, additional opinions can confirm or challenge the numbers you’re seeing. Real estate transactions can be complex—even more so when lines blur between representation and personal interest.
30. Mortgage Lenders, Title, and Escrow
In standard transactions, the buyer works with a mortgage lender (unless it’s a cash deal). Title and escrow companies handle the official transfer of ownership and the distribution of funds. If your agent is the buyer, confirm how their financing is structured. A legitimate lender will still require standard processes like appraisals and underwriting, which can serve as guardrails to protect you from an unfair valuation.
Title and escrow professionals can also be a line of defense; they may flag irregularities or ask for additional disclosures if they sense something unusual.
31. Final Thoughts
When your selling agent becomes your buyer, it can create an unusual dynamic where your best advocate might turn into an adversary—at least financially. This doesn’t mean every agent who wants to purchase a client’s property is doing something shady. Many times, such deals can be a win-win, offering convenience and a fair price. But the potential for conflict of interest is real, and it demands careful thought, transparent communication, and often an unbiased second opinion.
Throughout this post, we’ve covered everything from understanding the agent’s motivations, verifying market data, and negotiating repairs, to weighing the pros and cons of a quick off-market deal. We’ve also highlighted practical steps you can take—like insisting on a second opinion or consulting an attorney—to ensure you remain in the driver’s seat.
Above all, remember this: it’s your home and your equity at stake. You have every right to gather information, ask pointed questions, and walk away if something doesn’t feel right. An ethical real estate professional will respect your diligence.
Continue the Conversation
If you want more in-depth advice tailored to your unique situation, feel free to reach out via our contact page on SantaClaritaOpenHouses.com. While we’ve covered a lot of ground here, every real estate scenario is unique. Don’t hesitate to ask for the help or reassurance you need.
Thank you for taking the time to explore this topic! I’m Connor with Honor, and I hope this guide empowers you to navigate the sometimes murky waters of agent-as-buyer scenarios. If you have questions or experiences to share—good or bad—please drop a comment on my YouTube Short or on our website. Your stories can help others make more informed decisions.
** Share This Post## Comments
Already have an account? Yes NoLog In and Post CommentProtected by reCAPTCHA. Privacy • Terms
Explore
Connect
**Facebook**Twitter**Instagram**YouTube
🤝
Full Transparency
Yes, I earn referral fees when you work with agents I recommend. But unlike national platforms like Zillow or Realtor.com, I personally know and vet every single agent in my network of 17 trusted professionals.
My recommendations are based on YOUR specific needs and the complexity of your situation—not who pays the highest referral fee. I live in Santa Clarita Valley, and my reputation in this community depends on your success. Local accountability matters.
Ready to sell with a deliberate strategy?
Get seller-focused guidance built around your timeline, equity goals, and negotiation leverage.